Forgot password? | Register here

Editor's Picks

VP Nominee Sarah Palin

More Videos
Current Featured Debate

Closer Than He Should Be

Robert Novak | Primetime Politics

McCain Takes Aim at Obama’s Character

Ben Smith and Jonathan Martin | Politico

Audacity Overload

Kathryn Jean Lopez | National Review

Current Featured Debate

For the Republican Base, Palin Pick Is Energizing

Alec MacGillis | The Washington Post

U.S. Seizes Mortgage Giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

James R. Hagerty, Ruth Simon and Damian Paletta | The Wall Street Journal

Where Eagles Dare

Michael Yon | Michael Yon Online

Anbar’s Historic Moment

Tim S. McWilliams | Human Events

Afghanistan’s Communications Revolution

David A. Gross and Amir Zai Sangin | The Washington Post

A Heartbeat Away

William Kristol | The New York Times

China Outflanks U.S. With Iraqi Oil Deal

Damien McElroy | The New York Sun

The Mexican-American Drug War

Editorial | The Washington Times

What Did Obama Do As A Community Organizer?

Byron York | National Review



Article

Smear Redefined

Contentions | Spotlight by Bluestate 2 Comments Discuss
Added: May 14, 2008

Comment Email this Article Post an Article

Comments

I don’t see how this is a redefinition.  The author himself says that the word means to ‘contaminate the reputation of’.  Senator McCain is deliberatly contaminating the reputation of Senator Obama by associating him with Hamas.  A Hamas representative supports him so therefore he must support Hamas… It is pretty plainly a smear by the authors definition.  If is very clever on McCains part, while disengenous on the authors part to deny it.

Posted by helmut  on  05/14  at  04:42 PM

Helmut,

I agree that Sen. McCain purposely wanted to tie Obama’s name to Hamas, but I think you’re wrong in saying that “...supports him so therefore he must support Hamas.”

McCain in no way insinuated that Obama SUPPORTS Hamas, but rather was trying to starkly contrast their foreign policies and show that Hamas would not mind an Obama presidency while they shudder to think about a McCain presidency.

Posted by Aceman  on  05/15  at  08:17 AM

Name:

Email:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Comment Policy

Please keep comments on topic and civil. Comments deemed by the editors to be rude, obnoxious, mean-spirited, or off topic may be removed without notice